Long Island

Thanksgiving Made Simple: LI Takeout Picks

November 13, 2025 | What To Do

By: Kayla Carpio

Thanksgiving has a way of sneaking up on all of us and between busy schedules and the rush of the season, putting together a full holiday spread can feel overwhelming. Still, everyone deserves a table filled with comforting classics and a little extra time to enjoy the day. That’s where Long Island’s local restaurants and caterers come in, offering thoughtfully prepared dishes that bring the flavors of a home-cooked meal without the stress behind it. Whether you’re picking up a complete feast or adding a few standout sides to your table, these spots make it easy to celebrate with ease, warmth, and great food!

Golden Pear Cafe

Credit: Golden Pear Cafe

A Hamptons favorite for over 38 years, Golden Pear Cafe is bringing back its popular Thanksgiving catering menu at both the East Hampton and Southampton locations. Guests can order classic holiday staples like roasted turkey, herb stuffing, along with freshly baked pies and seasonal vegetable sides all prepared with the cafe’s signature homestyle touch. Golden Pear remains a beloved go-to on the East End. Orders must be placed by November 24th at 5:00 PM, both pickup and delivery options are available depending on location.

Art of Eating

Credit: Art of Eating

Art of Eating in Bridgehampton is offering a beautifully curated Thanksgiving menu made with fresh, local ingredients and thoughtful seasonal touches. Their lineup includes roasted Mecox Farms turkey, glazed ham and chef-crafted sides such as handmade gravies and rustic breads. Known for their detail-driven catering they bring an elevated feel to Thanksgiving while keeping the flavors familiar. Perfect choice for anyone hoping to enjoy a refined meal with an elevated feel. Orders must be placed by November 20th.

Sydney's "Taylor" Made Cuisine

Credit: Sydney's "Taylor" Made Cuisine

Sydney’s “Taylor” Made Cuisine in Westhampton is serving an abundant Thanksgiving takeout menu. Offering everything from hors d’oeuvres and entrees to sides and desserts. Enjoy delicious herb rubbed turkey or roasted lamb accompanied with baked acorn squash or chestnut stuffing. Finish off with their freshly baked pies or cheesecakes that will satisfy all your guests. This is an excellent option for families who love a festive meal with variety. Orders can be placed by emailing erin@sydneysgourmet.com.

Mercato Cucina

Credit: Mercato Cucina

Mercato Cucina in Huntington Station is preparing a complete Thanksgiving dinner that brings a homemade feel to the table. Their holiday package feeds 4 to 6 and includes curated items made by Chef David. From handmade stuffed shells and cranberry orange relish, to guanciale braised brussel sprouts, everything is crafted with quality ingredients, giving each dish a rich flavor. This is a wonderful option for families who want a meal made with passion. Reserve your dinner by calling 631-205-6340.

Tags:
What To Do