Long Island

Father’s Day Steakhouses

June 11, 2026 | What To Do

By: Ashley Rea

Father’s Day is the perfect excuse to gather the family and treat Dad to a memorable meal. While brunches and backyard barbecues have their place, nothing says celebration quite like a perfectly cooked steak, exceptional service, and an atmosphere designed for lingering over great food and conversation. From classic steakhouses with decades of history to modern destinations putting a fresh spin on the traditional steakhouse experience, Long Island offers plenty of options for making Dad feel appreciated this Father’s Day.

Holstein Grill Steakhouse

Credit: Holstein Grill Steakhouse

For families looking for a welcoming steakhouse experience with generous portions and something for everyone at the table, Holstein Grill Steakhouse is a standout choice. Known for its selection of expertly grilled steaks, the restaurant offers everything from New York strip and skirt steak to sirloin and specialty steak platters designed for sharing. The warm atmosphere strikes a balance between casual comfort and special-occasion dining, making it ideal for a Father’s Day gathering. Whether Dad prefers a classic steak dinner paired with traditional sides or enjoys exploring a menu filled with hearty favorites, Holstein Grill delivers the kind of satisfying meal that turns a family dinner into a celebration.

Jimmy Hays Steakhouse

Credit: Jimmy Hays Steakhouse

A Long Island institution, Jimmy Hays Steakhouse has been serving guests for generations while maintaining the timeless appeal of a classic New York steakhouse. The restaurant’s rich history and commitment to exceptional hospitality create an experience that feels both nostalgic and elevated. Alongside its renowned steaks and chops, the menu features standout starters including lobster bisque, Maryland crab cakes, and fresh seafood selections that complement any Father's Day feast. With its traditional atmosphere and longstanding reputation for quality, Jimmy Hays remains a favorite destination for families celebrating milestones and special occasions throughout the year.

Mavericks Montauk

Credit: Mavericks Montauk

For dads who appreciate both exceptional steak and stunning scenery, Mavericks Montauk offers a dining experience unlike any other on Long Island. The restaurant has earned attention for its ingredient-driven approach that combines wood-fired, dry-aged steaks with locally sourced seafood and seasonal produce. The result is a menu that feels distinctly East End while still delivering everything steak lovers crave. Situated on the shore of Fort Pond, the stylish waterfront setting, thoughtful wine program, and commitment to sustainable sourcing make Mavericks an excellent choice for families looking to elevate their Father’s Day celebration with a destination-worthy dining experience.

Rare650 Prime Steak & Sushi

Credit: Rare650 Prime Steak & Sushi

For a Father’s Day dinner that feels truly special, Rare650 combines the sophistication of a premier steakhouse with a contemporary dining experience. The Syosset favorite is known for its prime steaks, expertly crafted sushi, and striking design features, including a dramatic floor-to-ceiling wine room and stunning glass conservatory. Whether Dad is a traditional steak enthusiast or enjoys pairing a perfectly cooked cut with fresh sushi and creative cocktails, Rare650 offers a menu designed to impress. The upscale atmosphere and attention to detail make it a natural choice for families looking to celebrate Father’s Day with an unforgettable evening out.

Whether Dad prefers a classic steakhouse steeped in tradition, a waterfront destination with East End flair, or a contemporary dining experience complete with prime cuts and exceptional wine, these Long Island steakhouses offer memorable ways to celebrate Father’s Day. Reservations are recommended, as these popular destinations are sure to be in high demand for the holiday weekend.

Tags:
What To Do