Long Island

Where to Dine on Christmas Eve This Season

December 19, 2025 | What To Do

By: Kayla Carpio

Christmas Eve is a time to gather with loved ones and enjoy a memorable meal to kick off the holiday. Across the East End, restaurants are welcoming the season with special prix fixe menus, traditions, and thoughtfully crafted dishes that make the evening feel extra special. From seafood-forward feasts to classic holiday roasts, these Christmas Eve dinners offer a beautiful way to celebrate the night before Christmas.

Almond

Credit: Almond

At Almond in Bridgehampton, Christmas Eve is celebrated with their beloved annual suckling pig roast, a longstanding holiday tradition. The festive feast features locally raised suckling pig served with seasonal sides, creating a warm and comforting holiday meal. A portion of the evening’s proceeds benefits the Pajama Program, supporting children in need with pajamas and bedtime books. For guests who prefer other options, Almond’s full à la carte menu will also be available, making it a relaxed and meaningful way to spend Christmas Eve.

FĒNIKS

Credit: FĒNIKS

FĒNIKS in Southampton will offer a special Taste of Seven Fishes dinner on Christmas Eve, December 24, honoring the traditional Italian-American holiday feast. Created by veteran chef and restaurateur Douglas Gulija, the experience features a carefully curated multi-course menu highlighting fresh seafood, including local oysters, smoked salmon, tuna tartare, calamari, black sea bass, lobster, and striped bass. With one seating in the early evening, the dinner offers an intimate and refined way to celebrate Christmas Eve through a seafood-driven culinary tradition.

STELLA Trattoria & Bar

Credit: STELLA Trattoria & Bar

STELLA Trattoria & Bar is offering a holiday prix fixe menu on Christmas Eve, featuring a wide selection of Italian-inspired favorites. The multi-course menu allows guests to choose from a variety of appetizers, entrées, and desserts, including seafood, pasta, and classic Italian specialties. Thoughtfully curated and festive, STELLA’s Christmas Eve dinner blends tradition with comfort, making it a welcoming spot for gathering around the table before the holiday.

H2O Seafood & Sushi

Credit: H2O Seafood & Sushi

For those looking to celebrate Christmas Eve with a modern twist, H2O Seafood & Sushi will offer a special three-course prix fixe dinner for the evening. The menu includes a variety of seafood-focused appetizers, entrées, and desserts, giving guests plenty of options to customize their meal. Known for its fresh flavors and contemporary approach, H2O provides an elegant yet approachable setting to enjoy Christmas Eve dining.

Tags:
What To Do